Can you see it now? LaToya and Fantasia belting it out in the finals this May? Could happen.
What a difference a week makes. That was a pretty damn good group last night. Talent and passion took center stage, making this a tough call. Two clear-cut winners emerged and I believe America will get this one right.
Here's the talent of the third 8, top to bottom:
1. LaToya London
Strong, powerful voice, easily the best of the night. I wasn't as blown away as the judges, but she's clearly going deep into this competition. I thought she was borderline screaming some of those notes rather than singing them, but she put herself out there and really "brought it." I like her a lot. She could win it all if she tones it down just a bit.
2. Amy Adams
Excellent voice. Loved the daring way she opened in a acapella. Tremendous stage presence. Just a bundle of talent waiting to explode. If America gets this wrong, she's a lock for a wild card return.
3. Eric Yoder
Is America ready for a Clay Aiken-style singer again? Probably not. And this guy ain't Clay. But he's good. Smooth voice, polished and may be the best of the boys at this point. Nice falsetto move. Could land a wild card bid.
4. Elizabeth LeTendre
It sucks going first. With the phonies in Group 2 still ringing in my ears, it was refreshing to listen to real talent again. I was especially rooting for her because she's a local girl (Sturbridge, Mass.). She has a husky, unique voice and excellent stage presence. Looks a little like Kelly Clarkson. Could be a wild card.
5. Jon Peter Lewis
The Pen Salesman picks one of my favorite songs (Elton John's "Tiny Dancer," used for an emotional scene in "Almost Famous"), but doesn't sell it. You can tell the talent is there. Something was just missing. The girls love him. Would not be surprised to see him advance based on the chick vote. Plus, FOX needs some guys in the final 12.
6. Charly Lowry
It's nice to see diversity on stage (she's an American Indian). She has a unique, husky voice, but had a few pitch problems. I hate when singers say "c'mon" to the audience. It's not about audience participation. Just sing it. Much better than Camile Velasco, last week's winner.
7. Leah LaBelle
Simon's been drinking or popping peyote buttons on this one. "The best we've heard tonight" before LaToya's performance? Yecch. Very average. Sounded like she was half talking, half singing with an occasional yell. Pitch problems as well. Will be interesting to see if Simon swayed voters. Definitely has the best name for the music business.
8. Jonah Moananu
Seems like a nice guy but was well out of his league. Came across as a Ruben wannabe (and that's not saying much). Didn't seem to have a center; his voice was up and down too often for the simple style of song he was singing. If he was in Group 2, he may be headed to the final 12.