Perhaps the most entertaining Idol yet. The singers made the most of a good theme with excellent song choices. Unlike the last two seasons, there's no clear-cut favorite here. On a night when two of the front-runners were weak, the field is flattening out. And what's with the kissy-face banter between Simon and Paula? It's a tired routine. Just make your comments and move on. And now a revote. Is this a ploy to add another night (re: ad dollars). Whatever. Here's the order of how the 11 finalists performed last night, with the odds of winning it all in May:
1. Carrie Underwood
Best performance of the night. Finally, her breakthrough effort. Tough to tackle "Alone," a signature Ann Wilson classic. Wilson is one of rock's best vocalists. Thought she was a little shaky on the high notes, but handled herself well. Liked her new hairstyle. She's not going to win the whole thing (Simon is overreacting), but she'll easily crack the top 5.
Odds of winning: 5-1
2. Bo Bice
A close second. Excellent song choice, as Bo embraces the opportunity to show his softer side. Clearly a versatile performer, he'll pick up some new fans with this effort. From "Whipping Post" to "Time in a Bottle." Gotta love this guy. One of the few last night not competing with backup vocals. The focus was on Bo and he sounded great. Jim Croce would have loved this.
Odds of winning: 3-1
3. Nikko Smith (bottom 3)
Give this guy a full week to prepare and he delivers. Much, much better than last week, and his best performance to date. Thought he showed good vocal range. A little boy-bandish, but that's his style. Like the black suit. Not convinced he has the fan base, so would not be surprised to see him in the bottom 3. Deserves better.
Odds of winning: 12-1
4. Scott Savol
Where's Scott? He's still looking for his glasses. What goes through the minds of these performers under the spotlight? Very good job. Thought his vocals were clean, inspiring and thoughtful. Loved the sloppy shirt look. He's the everyman of the competition. Getting better each week. Velvety voice.
Odds of winning: 10-1
5. Vonzell Solomon
Wasn't crazy about the song, but she sang it well. A little over the top at times and there was too much going on -- loud backup vocals, dancing on Bo's auxiliary stage, singing to the judges -- and she seemed out of breath at times. She's a good singer and, like Scott, seems to be getting better each week.
Odds of winning: 8-1
6. Jessica Sierra
Tough, tough song to sing. The summer of '83 this song was everywhere. Thought she did OK. Some parts were good, but she had trouble enunciating the lyrics, making them indecipherable. Too bad, because these are great lyrics. Pace seemed a little fast as well, like she was rushing it. She'll probably escape the bottom 3 this week.
Odds of winning: 10-1
7. Anthony Federov (bottom 3)
Hated the song choice. Like Jessica, thought he had trouble enunciating the lyrics. The Wham sound just seems tired and irrelevant. Would have loved to see him sing something else. How about Styx' "Babe"? Thought he was pitchy and seemed uncomfortable on stage. Perhaps past negative comments from the judges have hurt his confidence. Still think he can sing, but this is a strong group.
Odds of winning: 10-1
8. Constantine Maroulis
Campy. Risky. Gotta love the Partridge Family, but it's an odd choice for him. Thought he did OK. Sang in tune, added some energy and clearly had fun with it. This isn't a song that lends itself to the vocals, so he was unable to move forward. Disappointing following last week's effort. Strong fan base will keep him around.
Odds of winning: 10-1
9. Anwar Robinson
Thought this guy was going to come out and devour the competition last night after a mediocre performance last week. Didn't happen. Backup singers overwhelmed him for most of the song, until the end. He has a great voice -- he just needs to find the song to showcase it. He'll need to step it up next week as some of his peers are catching up fast.
Odds of winning: 5-1
10. Nadia Turner
Awful. Disappointing. The one to beat took a week off. "Time After Time" is an awe-inspiring Cyndi Lauper classic that should send chills down your spine when it's sung well. Nadia just went through the motions. Her worst effort to date. Loved the Flock of Seagulls 'do. She's much better than this. Give her a mulligan.
Odds of winning: 3-1
11. Mikalah Gordon (bye, bye)
This is getting embarrassing. Thankfully she has a fun personality and doesn't seem to be bothered with the criticism. Thought she was off-key for most of the song. On a night when so many singers stepped it up, her weak vocals were magnified. The Cringe Factor comes into play here in a big way. Please send her home and let's move on.
Odds of winning: 55-1