Can we get a redo? It seems like there's some talent here, but nervousness was the theme of the evening. Clearly, the boys will rule American Idol IV when it's whittled down to the final 12. Other than a few, most of these girls were mediocre and unmemorable.
1. Aloha Mischeaux
Most talented of the group. Unique sound and style. Original. Fearless. Hated the song choice, but no one really came close to this performance. She'll be around in May, without a doubt, perhaps the one woman in the top 5 challenging the guys.
Odds of winning: 3-1
2. Carrie Underwood
Nice vocal controls. Hit all of her notes correctly in a difficult song. Had some Diana DeGarmo moments. The question is: How far will country take you? More talented than Carmen Rasmusen.
Odds of winning: 5-1
3. Nadia Turner
Best performance of the night. Perhaps the best stage presence of both gender. Came out with confidence, moved well, sang well. Her presence almost overwhelmed her vocals. Jeans and belly shirt worked. Big hair. Really big hair. Unique. Memorable.
Odds of winning: 8-1
4. Jessica Sierra
Loved the song choice ("Against All Odds"). Thought she sang it OK. Wasn't great. Seems like there's potential, once she handles her nerves. Like many of these, she seemed shell-shocked that she was actually performing in front of millions of people.
Odds of winning: 10-1
5. Vonzell Solomon
Pitchy, hit some bad notes, a little too runny. Was out of breath at times. Thought the judges were off on this one, but I just think they appreciate someone coming out with an uptempo song to open the show. Lots of energy, pretty. She needs another song.
Odds of winning: 17-1
6. Lindsey Cardinale
Safe, boring. Seemed like she was holding back. Another one battling nerves. Nasally. Cute. The guy vote will probably keep her around. Not impressed. Not memorable.
Odds of winning: 20-1
7. Celena Rae
Too subdued at the beginning. Very difficult to hear her. Sounded like she was mumbling. Picked it up midway and had a decent finish. Is there a voice here? Needs to come out with something strong if she sticks around.
Odds of winning: 20-1
8. Melinda Lira
Off-key, pitchy, too many awkward runs. Yet another one battling nerves. Hit a nice note at the end. Other than that, boring and forgettable.
Odds of winning: 20-1
9. Amanda Avila
Lots of emotion in her voice, but talent just doesn't match up to what lies ahead. Michael Bolton song a bad choice. Very safe and structured. Thought Simon's microphone comment was inappropriate.
Odds of winning: 25-1
10. Janay Castine
May have been the most nervous of all, and those nerves affected her performance. She hit a few good notes, but most were off-key. Bad song choice. She may get the sympathy vote as the judges were forgiving.
Odds of winning: 25-1
11. Sarah Mather
The song choice ("Get Ready") didn't work for her. Thought the performance was weak, and lacked emotion. It was like watching a Dramamine perform. Cute girl. Guy vote may keep her in, but she's out of her league here.
Odds of winning: 25-1
12. Mikalah Gordon
What was that? She was off-key, had trouble mouthing the lyrics and moved like Elaine Bennis. Thought she did OK during the auditions, so this was a surprise. Quirkiness may keep her around, but it's doubtful.
Odds of winning: 30-1