Did Paula Abdul want to make you throw up or what? What was with the tears one minute and the cheer-leading antics the next? She's shameful. It's tough to say goodbye to anyone at this point, but Kleenex sells tissues. Here's the order of how the six finalists performed last night, with the odds of winning it all next month:
1. Katharine McPhee (bottom 3)
Best of the night but the judges killed her, which will clearly affect the vote. Set the bar early with a flawless performance, cleavage and all. Powerful, subtle, passionate. She nailed Whitney, not easy to do. Here's hoping America can think for itself.
Odds of winning: 5-1
2. Elliott Yamin
Well, now. One of his best performances. It was obvious he put a lot of preparation into this. Difficult song choice with lots of chord changes, but he stayed on top of them and hit most of his notes. Deserves to stick around for another week, and he will.
Odds of winning: 15-1
3. Paris Bennett (bye, bye)
If the judges can tell Katharine she's not good enough to sing Whitney, they should have come down on Paris for singing Barbra. Nice job, no question, but she's no Streisand. Her recent history in the bottom 3 puts her at risk.
Odds of winning: 15-1
4. Chris Daughtry
Hated the arrangement. Spanish guitars? Thought he took forever to get into it but, as always, he managed to make an impact. Song didn't showcase his voice, but thought he worked his way through it. Judges were way too nice. Still the one to beat.
Odds of winning: 3-1
5. Kellie Pickler (bottom 3)
Anytime someone sings "Unchained Melody," you wait to see if they can hit "the note." Well, Ms. Pickler nailed that high note, but the rest of the performance was just average, like she was saving everything for the end. Kind of somber and safe.
Odds of winning: 8-1
6. Taylor Hicks
Worst performance of the night, but he has a huge fan base. Thought this was a very average vocal, and didn't match the talent of the others. Showed his usual passion toward the end, but it was too late. Is his luster fading?
Odds of winning: 10-1